I was startled today by the following link to a Yahoo News article on the Drudge Report website:
Fleeing conflict, elephants help Myanmar villagers to safety
You do see the problem, don't you? The headline has the elephants doing the fleeing instead of the Myanmar villagers.
I'm not making this up. In fact, here's the complete article, along with an AFP (Agence France-Presse) photo of one of the elephants, from which one of the villagers appears to be, well, dangling.
I thought immediately of an amusing old collection of grammar rules in which each rule violated itself. Specifically, I thought of my favorite, "When dangling, watch your participles."
What should the headline writer (I do not call him or her a journalist) have written instead?
There are a couple of possibilities. One is to write in passive voice:
Fleeing conflict, Myanmar villagers are helped to safety by elephants
However, if you are unalterably opposed to using passive voice (and I feel it in my bones that many of you are), you could simply move the misplaced modifier to its proper position in the headline:
Elephants help Myanmar villagers fleeing conflict to safety
I now close this fascinating post with a famous "droodle" by Roger Price called Four Elephants Examining an Orange:
The jury is still out on whether the orange is fleeing anything.
Hello, world! This blog began on September 28, 2007, and so far nobody has come looking for me with tar and feathers.
On my honor, I will do my best not to bore you. All comments are welcome
as long as your discourse is civil and your language is not blue.
Happy reading, and come back often!
And whether my cup is half full or half empty, fill my cup, Lord.
Copyright 2007 - 2025 by Robert H.Brague
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
<b>Closed captioning is still cuckoo</b>
We talked in a post not too long ago about the deficiencies of the current state of the art of voice recognition software (VRS) and closed ...
No comments:
Post a Comment